I suppose a lengthier title of this would be: “how to consume Harry Potter content without its transphobic author benefitting financially”. Because this is what I’ve been grappling with of late. This blog post therefore comes with a trigger warning about transphobia.
As regular readers of this blog will know, I am the father of a nine-year-old, albeit a nine-year-old with additional needs and who struggles with reading. We have had the odd conversation around Harry Potter, but so far there has been no desire to read the books, watch the films or engage in the fandom. This, of course, could change.
We have had some discussions with our nine-year-old around JK Rowling’s transphobic views, and why they’re bad. It helps that we can contextualise the situation, as one of our close friends is trans. But if all of their friends suddenly decide that they’re into Harry Potter, then we might need to handle this sensitively.
Whilst JK Rowling’s transphobia has been public knowledge for some time, the recent Supreme Court case around the definition of ‘woman’ was financially supported by her. In other words, if you’re spending money on Harry Potter books, films and merchandise, then you’re supporting transphobia. What I’m attempting to do is outline ways that you can do so without your money going to transphobic causes.
The books and the films
It just so happens that Christine already owns all of the books, and I have many of the DVDs of the films, so if our nine-year-old wants to consume them then they’re already there. If you have a child who wants to engage with the books and the films, but don’t already own them, then the best thing to do is buy them second-hand. That could be from a charity shop – even better if it’s for an LGBTQ+ positive charity – or on a site like eBay. Just make sure that you’re definitely buying a used copy.
In the UK at least, authors are recompensed when you borrow their books from the library. And whilst that’s generally a really good thing, it’s not helpful this situation. You also don’t want to be streaming the films on Netflix either.
When it comes to problematic authors from the past, the situation is a little different. For example, HP Lovecraft held views that we would now consider to be racist. However, he is dead, and therefore he can’t actively fund legal action against marginalised groups. And, his oldest work is now out of copyright anyway, so you can download some of his work from Project Gutenberg for free. This is also an argument about why you should boycott Tesla, and not other car companies like Volkswagen who may have supported fascism in the past, but not now. At least, as far as I’m aware.
The new Harry Potter TV series
Just don’t watch it. Indeed, if enough people don’t watch it, they won’t make any more, and it may indicate how toxic the Harry Potter brand is becoming.
Merchandise
Again, buy second-hand if you must. Also, there’s no shortage of unofficial ‘teenage wizard’ merchandise and fancy dress outfits that you could consider. Maybe avoid the dubious tax-avoiding ones that have cropped up all over London though.
But also, consider having the difficult conversation with your kids about the nature of Harry Potter and its writers’ views. Parenting is hard, and trying to go against peer pressure and your child’s desire to fit in can be harder still.
Alternatives
You could steer your child towards other books, films and TV series that are less problematic. We recently read Lee Bacon’s ‘The Last Human’ (sponsored link) which is a really good book and aimed at a similar age group. Others have said good things about Tomi Adeyemi’s ‘Children of Blood and Bone’ (sponsored link), which is the first in a three-part series. I have the Kindle edition of the first book, but I haven’t read it myself yet. Both of these books have film adaptations in the works. Currently, we’re reading SCRAP by Guy Bass (sponsored link) which is also very good, and there are the ‘junior’ Discworld books by Terry Pratchett as well.
I thought about this when all the controversy about her views first blew up and concluded anyone dramatically getting rid of their Harry Potter books wouldn’t make any difference as JK Rowling has already had the money. I saw a few people demanding refunds from her but that never happened to my knowledge. I see the books in charity shops and secondhand bookshops all the time. Buying the books or DVDs from a private seller on the likes of eBay should work as well.
A topic I struggle with frequently. When you find out that someone whose work you’ve enjoyed, sometimes for decades, turns out to be a shitty human being – what do you do?
I don’t claim to have an answer to that.
I’ve written a couple times about my love of The Smiths. After crafting the soundtrack to my youth, Morrissey’s views on race and politics are incredibly problematic. I find I’m conflicted.